There Was a Trick in the Bible’s Miracle of the Loaves and Fishes. Science Has Just Uncovered It

While science doesn’t aim to question Jesus’ ability to multiply food, it turns out that something similar can occur in the real world.

Bible
No comments Twitter Flipboard E-mail

All four Gospels of the Bible document one of Jesus’ most well-known “miracles.” According to the Holy Scripture, large crowds gathered to see him. They waited so long that they began to starve. Defying all logic, he took five loaves of bread and two fish, and miraculously, the food began to multiply, allowing him to feed everyone present. Recently, experts have tried to explain the “miracle” scientifically.

The meaning of miracles. Research published in Water Resources Research suggests that there may be a straightforward natural explanation for one of Jesus’ most famous miracles. The recent scientific study doesn’t aim to validate Jesus’ existence or interpret the Bible’s depictions of his extraordinary acts. Instead, it seeks to offer a scientific perspective on this seemingly impossible event, though perhaps it isn’t as impossible as we thought.

The unusual events reported at the Sea of Galilee in today’s Israel may actually result from an interesting natural phenomenon.

Biblical context and the Sea of Galilee. The Sea of Galilee, also known as Lake Tiberias or Kinneret, is a freshwater lake in Israel that’s mentioned multiple times in the Bible in connection with the miracles of Jesus. Two of the most notable miracles involving the lake are the “Feeding of the 5,000” and the “Miraculous Catch of Fish.”

In the “Feeding of the 5,000,” Jesus feeds at least 5,000 people with just five loaves of bread and two fish that a child had. In the “Miraculous Catch of Fish,” the apostles experience a tremendous catch of fish after following Jesus’ instructions.

What science says. Researchers suggest that these “miracles” may have a scientific explanation related to a phenomenon known as “fish kill” in the lake. It turns out that these kinds of events can occur, resulting in a large number of dead fish near the shore. This could explain why fish were so abundant during the time of the biblical accounts, provided the events actually occurred.

The study highlights that the fish kill phenomenon is caused by a process called “upwelling.” Upwelling occurs when oxygen-depleted water from the deeper layers of the lake rises to the surface due to internal waves generated by wind. This typically happens during the summer when the lake is stratified into layers: a warm layer on the surface, a colder one at the bottom, and an intermediate layer with a significant temperature gradient.

As a result, fish become trapped in the oxygen-poor water when these layers mix and may suffocate near the surface.

Documented events and conclusions. Although the phenomenon is rare in Lake Kinneret, experts have recorded recent cases of fish kills in 2012, 2007, and during the 1990s. They all occurred near the Tabgha area, which is associated with the miracles of Jesus. Similar incidents have also happened in other locations, such as Lake Erie, on the International Boundary between Canada and the U.S., and the Neuse River estuary in North Carolina.

In conclusion, the recent study suggests that these fish kill events, or the concentration of live fish near the shore due to partial upwelling, may have inspired the biblical stories that emerged more than 2,000 years ago. Researchers further conclude that the area’s specific location and climatic conditions may have facilitated these kinds of events, providing a more accurate explanation for the fish miracles in the Sea of Galilee.

Image | The Met

Related | While Searching for Dinosaurs in Argentina, Scientists Discover a 161-Million-Year-Old Treasure: The Oldest Tadpole on the Planet

Home o Index